Ventura Martinez v. Trump et al.

Carlos Ventura Martinez is a Maryland resident of 12 years who fled El Salvador’s gang violence in 2013, worked as a painter, paid taxes, and supported his three sons until ICE detained him in a June 2025 immigration raid (that was focused on someone else entirely) on his way to work.

An immigration judge found he wasn’t a flight risk and set bond, but the Board of Immigration Appeals reversed that ruling under a new government interpretation of an old law. That interpretation, previously limited to people seeking admission at the border, is now being used to argue that longtime U.S. residents like Carlos must be held without bond — a policy that could expose millions of people to mandatory detention regardless of how long they’ve lived here.

On October 22, 2025, a district court granted Carlos a temporary restraining order, ruling that the mandatory detention statute’s plain text doesn’t apply to longtime residents like him and that he’s likely to prevail on that argument. The court ordered the government to let him post bond under the immigration judge’s original terms — he paid and went home. Two days later, on October 24, 2025,  the government filed notice it’s appealing to the Fifth Circuit.”

This case remains pending as the full Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals decides on Sosnava Rodriguez v. Ortega at which point further briefing may continue or the case may be remanded to the lower court for reconsideration.

Stay Informed