Our client, a transgender woman who spent a year in immigration jail, was granted Convention Against Torture (CAT) protections in March 2025 when an immigration judge found she faced risk of torture or death if returned to Mexico due to her gender identity. CAT protection carries the force of law and prohibits the government from deporting someone to a country where they would face torture. In November 2025, ICE violated her CAT protection and deported her to Mexico anyway.
Our client managed to survive in Mexico, living in constant fear for her safety, before the U.S. government admitted wrongdoing and was forced to allow her to return to the United States. Upon her return, and despite ICE’s flagrant violation of the law, ICE refused to release her, arguing that a prior conviction justified her redetention in an all-male facility, with no end in sight.
Although our client initially lost her bid for release to the federal court, on a motion for reconsideration, that same court ordered her freed. The court found that, despite ICE’s representations about efforts to deport our client, they were no closer to deporting her now than they were a year ago. The decision centers on a fundamental constitutional principle: immigration detention is civil, not criminal, and cannot be used to punish people.
A federal court ordered the release of our client in March, 2026.