Salaruddin Eqbal, an Afghan man who served in security roles protecting high-ranking officials in the U.S.-backed Afghan government, fled Taliban persecution in 2023. He came to the U.S. in 2024 and was detained and placed in removal proceedings.
Proceeding without an attorney, Eqbal testified before an immigration judge and sought asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture. The immigration judge denied all relief, finding Eqbal not credible based largely on apparent inconsistencies regarding his employment history and his prior imprisonment.
On August 6, 2026, the U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals vacated the immigration court’s denial of asylum in a rare published decision. The court found that the immigration judge’s adverse credibility determination, the sole basis for denying Eqbal protection, was not supported by the record and appeared to rest on translation errors and misunderstandings rather than any actual inconsistency in his testimony.
The Fifth Circuit’s decision vacates the Board of Immigration Appeals’ dismissal of Eqbal’s case and remands it for further proceedings, directing the agency to reconsider his credibility without relying on the flawed findings and to meaningfully evaluate the evidence he submitted. Eqbal is still detained and has been relocated from River Correctional Facility to the Houston Contract Detention Facility in Texas.